Factsheet

Resource reviewed
Title The Making and Knowing Project. Intersections of Craft Making and Scientific Knowing
Editors Pamela H. Smith, Naomi Rosenkranz, Tianna Helena Uchacz, Tillmann Taape, Clément Godbarge, Sophie Pitman, Jenny Boulboullé, Joel Klein, Donna Bilak, Marc Smith, Terry Catapano
URI https://www.makingandknowing.org/bnf-ms-fr-640/
Publication Date 2020
Date of last access 05.05.2025
Reviewer
Name orcid-icon Lang, Sarah
Affiliation Max Planck Institute for the History of Science
Place Berlin
Email slang@mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de
Documentation
Bibliographic description
Is it easily possible to describe the project bibliographically along the schema “responsible editors, publishing/hosting institution, year(s) of publishing”?
yes
Contributors
Are the contributors (editors, institutions, associates) of the project fully documented?
yes
Contacts
Does the project list contact persons?
yes
Selection
Is the selection of materials of the project explicitly documented?
yes
Reasonability of the selection
Is the selection by and large reasonable?
yes
Archiving of data
Does the documentation include information about the long term sustainability of the basic data (archiving of the data)?
yes
Aims
Are the aims and purposes of the project explicitly documented?
yes
Methods
Are the methods employed in the project explicitly documented?
yes
Data model
Does the project document which data model (e.g. TEI) has been used and for what reason?
yes
Help
Does the project offer help texts concerning the use of the project?
yes
Citation
Does the project supply citation guidelines (i.e. how to cite the project or a part of it)?
yes
Completion
Does the editon regard itself as a completed project (i.e. not promise further modifications and additions)?
yes
Institutional curation
Does the project provide information about institutional support for the curation and sustainability of the project?
yes
Contents
Previous edition
Has the material been previously edited (in print or digitally)?
no
Materials used
Does the edition make use of these previous editions?
not applicable
Introduction
Does the project offer an introduction to the subject-matter (the author(s), the work, its history, the theme, etc.) of the project?
yes
Bibliography
Does the project offer a bibliography?
yes
Commentary
Does the project offer a scholarly commentary (e.g. notes on unclear passages, interpretation, etc.)?
yes
Contexts
Does the project include or link to external resources with contextual material?
yes
Images
Does the project offer images of digitised sources?
yes
Image quality
Does the project offer images of an acceptable quality?
yes
Transcriptions
Is the text fully transcribed?
yes
Text quality
Does the project offer texts of an acceptable quality (typos, errors, etc.)?
yes
Indices
Does the project feature compilations indices, registers or visualisations that offer alternative ways to access the material?
yes
Types of documents
Which kinds of documents are at the basis of the project?
Single manuscript
Document era
What era(s) do the documents belong to?
Early modern
Subject
Which perspective(s) do the editors take towards the edited material? How can the edition be classified in general terms?
History, History of Science
Spin-Offs
Does the project offer any spin-offs?
None
Access modes
Browse by
By which categories does the project offer to browse the contents?
Pages, Images
Simple search
Does the project offer a simple search?
yes
Advanced search
Does the project offer an advanced search?
yes
Wildcard search
Does the search support the use of wildcards?
yes
Index
Does the search offer an index of the searched field?
no
Suggest functionalities
Does the search offer autocompletion or suggest functionalities?
no
Help texts
Does the project offer help texts for the search?
no
Aims and methods
Audience
Who is the intended audience of the project?
Scholars, Interested public
Typology
Which type fits best for the reviewed project?
Enriched edition
Critical editing
In how far is the text critically edited?
Transmission examined, Palaeographic annotations, Normalization, Variants, Commentary notes
XML
Is the data encoded in XML?
yes
Standardized data model
Is the project employing a standardized data model (e.g. TEI)?
yes
Types of text
Which kinds or forms of text are presented?
Facsimiles, Diplomatic transcription, Edited text, Translations, Commentaries
Technical accessability
Persistent identification
Are there persistent identifiers and an addressing system for the edition and/or parts/objects of it and which mechanism is used to that end?
DOI
Interfaces
Are there technical interfaces like OAI-PMH, REST etc., which allow the reuse of the data of the project in other contexts?
None
Open Access
Is the edition Open Access?
yes
Accessability of the basic data
Is the basic data (e.g. the XML) of the project accessible for each part of the edition (e.g. for a page)?
yes
Download
Can the entire raw data of the project be downloaded (as a whole)?
yes
Reuse
Can you use the data with other tools useful for this kind of content?
yes
Declaration of rights
Are the rights to (re)use the content declared?
no
License
Under what license are the contents released?
Other: Couldn’t find rights declaration but it seems implied that reuse is permitted
Personnel
Editors Bilak, Donna
Boulboullé, Jenny
Catapano, Terry
Godbarge, Clément
Klein, Joel
Pitman, Sophie
Rosenkranz, Naomi
Smith, Marc
Smith, Pamela
Taape, Tillmann
Uchacz, Tianna Helena
Programmers Catapano, Terry
Advisors Gil, Alex
Contributors Abruzzi, Ray
Ahmed, Atif
Anantharaman, Divya
Atkinson, Jo Kirby
Beentjes, Tonny
Bol, Marjolijn
Buscarino, Bella
Chaillard, Dana
Cherian, Philip
Debuiche, Colin
Elmer, Hannah
Glenhaber, Linus
Hermens, Erma
Hu, Bingyan
Hu, Christine
Kaufman, Roni
Kumar, Matthew
Kumar, Mehul
Lacey, Andrew
Lyautey, Margot
Macahilig, Christian
Maragi, Varsha
Mehrish, Divya
Munoz, Sarah
Nahley, Charlotte
Palframan, Jeffrey
Patel, Nilam
Pensack, Miriam
Rechberg, Carolin
Sabel, Claire
Schare, Gregory
Shende, Tanisha
Shulman, Camilla
Sonnenberg, Scott
Stijnman, Ad
Suryanarayanan, Sharan
Tetik, Emre
Touze-Peiffer, Ludovic
Troth, Kelsey
Vandermel, Jacklyn
Vandermel, Katie
Vandermel, Katie
Vikram, Karuna
Wayno, Jeffrey